Trying to find a way to consume self-rising flour, I decided to conduct a food experiment on using self-rising flour vs all-purpose flour with the exact same ingredients, under 2 different overnight rising conditions: room temperature vs fridge. These 2 variables (flour and rising condition) gave me 4 different pizza dough with 4 different texture. Sharing my food experiment process, results, observation here! Also attached the pizza toppings I used ๐ Enjoy!
QUICK TAKEAWAYS:
- Self-rising flour pizza dough is thinner and crispier than all-purpose flour pizza dough which is thicker and softer
- Fridge overnight rising pizza dough rise less than room temperature overnight rising pizza dough, and is crispier. RT rising dough might have sour taste from fermentation.
- Personal favorite: all-purpose flour dough rising in fridge overnight
- Watch out for wet topping with tomato sauce and cheese
- Try to moist drier topping with cheese and olive oil
- No pizza stone? Overlay 2 baking pan, turn upside down to mimic pizza stone
- Preheat baking pans/pizza stone with oven to highest temperature so when the pizza is added on, heat comes from bottom upwards, cooking the thicker crust, without burning toppings or have uncooked crust.
RECIPE
Part I: Day 1 making dough
4 mini pizza with 4 different conditions of 2 flours: all-purpose flour vs self-rising flour.
Self-Rising Flour | All Purpose Flour | |
flour | 250g | 250g |
salt | NA | 2g |
oil | 12.5g | 12.5g |
yeast | 1g | 1g |
RT water | 175g | 175g |
self-rising flour all-purpose flour
Process:
- activate yeast with water, mix well
- mix flour, salt and oil
- add in yeast + water
- form a soft dough, no need to knead yet
- rest 20mins
- knead dough till surface is smooth
- ** rest again and knead if surface breaks
- cut dough into half (each for overnight-rising condition)
- coat 4 dough with olive oil
- ** if want to eat softer, bread-like pizza dough, can add more yeast, rise and bake pizza same day
Four conditions:
Self-rising flour, fridge overnight | All-purpose flour, fridge overnight |
Self-rising flour, RT overnight | All-purpose flour, RT overnight |

self-rising, RT all-purpose, RT
RT overnight: stronger alcohol taste, more sour dough, will taste more crispy
Fridge overnight: in between bread-like and crispy textur
Observation: dough in fridge did not rise much; dough in RT double their sizes
Part II: Day 2 Pizza Dough & Baking
- ** if do not have pizza stone ** lay two baking pan on top of each other, in mimic the thickness of pizza stone, and prevent heat from fluctuating too much.
- turn baking pans-set upside down, the bottom on top, put in oven.
- preheat oven to 550F or oven’s highest temperature
- degas
- knead dough into smoother surface
- rest & rise for 2 hours at RT, cover with cloth/plastic wrap
before 2 hour rising after 2 hour rising
- slightly press down to dough, forming a circle shape dough
- grab onto the edge of the dough, let the weight of dough stretch the dough; move where your fingers grab on till the whole dough’s edge has been stretch
- not using a roller so won’t break air bubble
- add pizza topping

- bake 5-6 mins
- mine took around 10mins, a lot of liquid/juice from tomato sauce and cheese

before baking after baking
Pizza Dough Crust Texture Comparison:
self-rising, fridge
crispy, dry, thinAP, fridge
between crispy and soft! LOVE IT!self-rising, RT
crispy, dry, thinAP, RT
more bread like? thicker from rising?
BONUS: Pizza Toppings
“Margarita” without basil leaves (top right and bottom right):
- tomato sauce at the bottom (tried 2 different tomato sauce)
- halved-grape tomato, corn
- mozzarella
- Comment: be careful about liquid from tomato sauce and cheese. Could end up with a really wet pizza..!

“Meat Sauce” pizza (top left):
- spicy pasta meat sauce at the bottom
- halved-grape tomato, corn
- Comment: flavor too strong for pizza; texture very dry

Pesto Potato pizza (bottom left):
- seed mix:
- oregano
- sesame seeds
- lemon zest (I do not have)
- cumin
- pinch of both salt and pepper
- bottom: olive oil
- sprinkle seed mix
- spread pesto
- layer potato
- sprinkle rest of seed mix
- sprinkle olive oil
- add burrata ( I don’t have either)
- Comment: flavorful but a bit dry, because no burrata or not enough olive oil?

Resource